trismugistus reviewed Version 1 -
Read 100%% of the Item
Admittedly it’s difficult to review just a prologue, and this is perhaps more a reflection of my personal feelings, but I prefer prologues to not feel like they’re just a short chapter.
Obviously, I’ve not read chapter 1, because of how this works, but to me, unless your prologue here stops, and the story is going somewhere else entirely, why not just make it part of a proper chapter? In other words, a Prologue, to me, should ‘kick in’ to the story much later – it should have an “Oh, I see…” quality to it, and I don’t get that feeling here.
In the prologue, you shouldn’t reveal too much – like the detail about him being a cat-type lycan, etc, because (if they’re important) you want those to come as a surprise.
I mean, I would also recommend doing that anyway – for example, have him change, yes, but it’s better to let your readers discover things (Jason’s horror at seeing him change into a cat) than just tell them (“I’m a cat Lycan.”). Similarly, you could, for example, have a great scene where Taylor comes out (as it were) for the first time, and show his Dad and family’s reactions. But since you’ve just told us in a single line he’s a cat Lycan and that that’s unusual, you loose that opportunity. Hope that makes sense :).
Basically, I’d recommend an approach of taking your time and letting things come out naturally. Even down to how he tells us his name is Taylor and he’s 17, but you then have a perfectly naturally bit of dialouge where it comes out, but you’ve already told us, so the first one seems redundant.
Hope that’s of some use.