WaywardSonRising reviewed Version 1 -
Read 100% of the Item
very well done for the style that you’ve chosen. it is minimal in length and information, but the feeling and scene is conveyed clearly and efficiently, not an easy task when dealing with so few words. you do need some paragraph breaks though, even if the piece is brief. then only real hiccups that i saw inn the writing were the lines where she had a “slightly toothless, grin” and whre she fishes ot the cigarette. first just think about what your saying- how can you be “slightly” and “toothless”?one word means “a little bit” and the other means “completely without teeth”, and the two do more clashing than mixing when read together (in my humble opinion, mind you). second, cigarettes come in packs and i dont think i’ve ever met a person who carries loose ones around in their pocket, because they are fragile. so how did this kid reach in and fish out a single cigarette? very very nimble fingers i suppose? even then, that part is still a bit ackward that she would just stroll up and reach into someones pocket- thats a very VERY brash move, even for a naiver little girl. kids often talk to strangers, wave,or strike up random conversations, but id bet its one in a million or so that will reach into your pocket. and besides, it might open up the chance for a little dialouge if the little girl asked him for something of his, instead of jsust taking it. food for thought. anyway, on the whole good stuff. it was brief, well put together, and kept my interest. not only that but the ending was dark and not at all dissapointing. well done.