tia_logic reviewed Version 1 -
Read 100% of the Item
First, your internal and half rhymes are pretty fun. It’s inconsistant, too, mixed with end rhymes—making a subtler effect.
I have a few hangups with the metaphors in places—for the image painted. In stanza one: a sun on the horizon, blazing. Ok, so I’m following you with the shadow motif. What throws me is that where there are shadows, something has to cast them, blocking light. Which follows that where there are shadows, there is light. The first lines, for me, create an image of a sun (though dark) rising—I think “on the horizon” is usually construed as a beginning. After that first line, however, I think it dives into word play which overshadows the meaning. I can appreciate that, alliteration. However, all I’m getting from this is some picture of a place where folks are scared, things are scary. And it doesn’t evoke anything from me.
I would rethink a few places which were especially strained to me, personally. S2 lines 1&2 – brewing, literally, like fermenting? internally, like fixating on fear? covered in filth? I’d try another way to make your meaning more clear.
S3 the bright eyes/cry/wisdom weeping. This doesn’t follow, for me. Is it that the bludgeoned are losing wsdom? Or gaining it in the aftermath? Neither of those make cognitive sense to me, all poetic aspects aside.
Anyway, my two cents. Good luck!