smessler reviewed Version 3 -
Read 100% of the Item
I found it a little off-putting that this is written in the present tense rather than the past. That is not necessarily a bad thing; if it ultimately works, do it. Just don’t do it for the sake of rattling your reader. Do it because your story needs to be set at the exact moment the reader is reading the sentence.
Yes, I know that many stories have been written in the present tense, and to great effect. However, make sure that it does add a better effect. Basically, if you can change it from the present tense to the past tense, and the story remains seemingly the same, I would keep it in the past tense.
Just makes it easier for the reader.
The main reason I point this out is because this seems like it is going to be an action-adventure story, a la Indiana Jones (or Allan Quatermain, since we are in the literature field). Though you have probably already read them, check out The Celestine Prophecy or Angels & Demons/The Da Vinci Code. Those are adventures, much the same as this one (or, at least that’s what I picked up from it). Notice those books don’t try any tricks with the writing; they are straightforward in their narrative.
Calling your protagonist “Professor Steadman” throughout the entire story is going to get tiresome. His name is first given in a quote. Let the title of Professor Steadman stay in quotations. When you as the author refer him to your readers, just call him “Steadman”.
Your writing is a little too on the nose. You describe everything quickly and concisely, which is good, but you tend to get to the point too quickly. I felt no suspense while reading this. Yes, it’s an introduction, and is supposed to introduce you to the action right away. But, that’s why it makes it even more important to give the reader some suspense.
The reader doesn’t need to be told exactly what the perimeters look like. They don’t need to know each and every action that every character does. What the reader really wants to know is: 1.) what is the mood and 2.) what is the conflict.
The mood and the conflict are what you need to be informing your reader of, not what a room looks like, or, as it happened here, what a room used to look like.
Overall, though, it does have the elements of what could be a gripping adventure. I would use more of your personal voice in it, make the narrative more conversational than technical. It’ll also allow you to throw a bit more humor into the text, which is good for an adventure.