Short Story / Left for Dead in Witchita (Analysis)

Left for Dead in Wichita

It’s one of my favorite stories, you know?  I was eighteen years old and I begged you to go. Nothing doing, I wanted to see the west because I’d never been beyond Indianapolis. That was back when the sex was still new and my influence was like a drug.  I had the kind of pull on you that only new love has. It only took the look and the plea and you couldn’t resist, so to Wichita we went.  

I had no idea it was a town the size of Portsmouth, except flat.  (Of course you know how I am, no one could have told me anything.)  No interesting architecture, no tall buildings, nothing remotely resembled a state capitol at all.  It looked like an old factory town after the factory had gone bust, leaving in its wake a depressed city full of filthy, seedy, pay by the hour motels.  One after another, their rates boldly displayed on the marquis’ out front  with letters partially missing beckoning to potential customers. The signs themselves dilapidated, hazards of falling over and harming passers-by.  My jaw gaped open as I took in the tired sites.  Amazed yet so disappointed.  I’d heard of things like this, even seen them on television, but here it was in real life, I could not believe my eyes.  An actual pay by the hour motel where one could meet a lover or worse-a prostitute!  I was horrified.  The new civic center, dog track and modern chain hotel about ten miles out of town, in stark contrast to the dismal inner city, seemed to be waiting for the population to grow up around it, appeared to have high hopes for new development.  

As you well remember, you went to check into that new hotel outside the city and I stayed in the truck. As I sat there, I saw a newer Ford F350 four door dually with a ground effects package parked in front of us and noticed personalized license plate, “QTRHRS”.   After having been through the down trodden city we’d just toured and seeing the string pay by the hour motels, I was appalled by the license plate and now more convinced than ever that we had come to the very den of iniquity my sweet little church going grandmother had warned me about.  As soon as you got into the truck, I said, “Look! Look at that license plate! Can you believe they’re advertising it right on there in plain sight?”

“What,” you asked calmly but confused.

In the time I’d had time to consider the  type of vehicle it was, since we were in the west, I thought, it would certainly be almost like a limo.  “Well, I bet you could get a lot of people in one of those things.”  I even imagined it pulling a trailer full of ladies of the evening, them waving at gentlemen as it passed by.

“What are you talking about,” you asked more confused.

“Don’t you see the license plate? See it? Q-T-R-H-R-S! It’s an advertisement,” and I didn’t just say it, I clearly and emphatically exclaimed, “Cuter Whores!”  

You looked at the license plate, then slowly turned and looked at me with what I now realize might have been pity and placed your hand on mind. “Honey, do you think, just judging from the vehicle—maybe it means quarter horse?”

I remember holding your look of disenchantment for only a moment as the blood rushed to my face. I also recall staring briefly at the ‘Ranger XLT’ crest on the dash and trying to make an appropriate acronym out of it.

Really
Anal retentive
Naïve
Girl
Exposes
Roots
Then I got to the “X” and gave up.

And when I tell that story I always end it by saying, “I swear, I still don’t why he didn’t just open the door, push me out and leave me for dead in Wichita!  I certainly deserved it!”  Yet, as many times as I’ve told that story and laughed, I had a sudden epiphany today when I told it and realized that I truly was left for dead in Wichita.  

A few years ago I asked you, when discussing that trip if you had married me for what you saw-the ‘raw, unfinished’ me, the me who came to you as I was, or if you had made sort of an investment in me for the potential you hoped I could be after a bit of polishing and exposure to the elements of life.  And you said ‘both,’ that Wichita only confirmed what you already knew, which was that I very much needed to get out of Adams County.  

Until today, I had only thought of it as a long, lousy trip that ended with a really funny story to tell.  Now, after two decades, I see that it was a belated lesson learned.  Wichita showed me the boundless depth of your patience.  I became fully aware of your compassion because it may have taken nearly twenty years, but I now realize you never laughed about it until I was able to laugh about it.  You never laughed at me.   And most of all you still chose me, and you loved me no less after I proved in grand fashion how much I had to learn.  

So, sweetheart, it may seem like a silly thing to say, but I was left for dead in Wichita.  It was where I shed my proverbial skin.  For a such a flat state, Kansas was where my world took shape and got much bigger than Adams County.  There was some version of me that died, some childish, immature version of me that I happily left behind when you held my gaze and my hand unwavering.  I knew without a doubt that you saw me with all my flaws (even the ones I took such pains to hide) and all that I was not (and maybe never would be), and you saw the road that lay ahead and you still signed on for it, Wichita and all.  

You know, I don’t think I ever thanked you and I realize it‘s a little late.  For that I‘m sorry, but from the bottom of my heart I thank you for Wichita and every little thing it means.  Perhaps more than that, I thank you in advance for all the Wichita’s to come. I wouldn’t trade it or you or this life for anything in the whole world.

You need to log in to urbis or create an urbis account to review this writing.

Reviews

Sort Reviews by  Newest |  Oldest |  Highest Quality |  Lowest Quality |  Newest Comments | 

 
HMStocker avatar General Stranger

July 24, 2008

HMStocker

personal info reviewer stats
HMStocker reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item
This 180 word review has not been unlocked.
blossom_art avatar General Stranger

April 16, 2008

blossom_art

personal info reviewer stats
blossom_art reviewed Version 1 - Read 100%% of the Item
This 179 word review has not been unlocked.
Curtastrophe avatar General Stranger

April 02, 2008

Curtastrophe

REVIEW QUALITY: 100.0%(1 vote ) personal info reviewer stats
Curtastrophe reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

I really like how this story is written. It’s nice how you use “you” to address the husband in the story, but it also makes the experience unique for the reader – the reader feels like they’re in the husband’s place, reading a letter they found conspicuously placed on the kitchen table, or in an envelope along with some anniversary flowers. Now for a few pointers:  

”...he marquis’…” – Should be ‘marquees’.

”...or worse-a prostitute!...” – I’d switch they hyphen for a comma.

“QTRHRS” Hahaa! At first I thought this stood for “quarter hours”, like it was an advertisement for the hotel that a person could rent a room for fifteen minutes. But that still seemed a bit odd. I’m glad the narrator explained her interpretation later on. Even better, the husband suggests it might stand for “quarter horses.”

I’d suggest placing a space between “Roots” and “Then I…” IMO doing this would give the reader a momentary break, then give them the “punchline” of sorts.

As it ends, we find out that Wichita but more specifically “QTRHRS” acted as a catalyst for the narrator to truly realize a few personal aspects of her life. This (I think) happens to all of us from time to time, and of course our “Wichita’s” or “QTRHRS” take all different shapes and forms. It ended quite sweetly though at the beginning I thought it would end in tragedy. The story definitely took on a different course than I expected it to, and this is always a good thing. A good read. Thanks for sharing.

-Curt  

trismugistus avatar General Stranger

April 02, 2008

trismugistus

REVIEW QUALITY: 100.0%(2 votes ) personal info reviewer stats
trismugistus reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

These are the ones I hate to review, because the only thing that’s really wrong with the story is things like the odd dropped word, or a slight clumsiness of grammar here and there, and that would probably all be sorted by yourself in a redraft.

My only general points on that front would be that some of your paragraphs tend to run on a little long and could do with being broken up a little.  Also, some of the sentences would be better joined together using semi-colons and dashes, rather than chopped off with full-stops.  Lastly, some phrases, like “pay by the hour” could be joined with dashes, though that’s personal preference.

As I saw, in terms of the stories structure, what you say, the point you’re making and how the story is told, I personally find all to be just right.  Perhaps there’s a slight tendency to unnecessary repetition – the paragraph explaining the motels and towards the end explaining how you (proverbially) died perhaps could be shaved a little tighter, but it’s nothing dramatic.

I’ll understand if you want a refund on this review, as it’s not particularly helpful, other than to say redraft for grammar.  Good job :).

StealthShifter avatar General Stranger

April 02, 2008

StealthShifter

REVIEW QUALITY: 100.0%(1 vote ) personal info reviewer stats
StealthShifter reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

Sweety, I don’t know who else to call you, I am still crackin’ up.  And it was lovely, and I’m so glad it wasn’t just the first page I saw that was the story – though it wouldn’t have been a bad one.  As for all the ratings and rankings for short stories, I have no clue, but I feel that it should be publishable somewhere!  You’ve got plot, humor, characters and place.  

The one thing that I’d recommend (but follow your heart) is a little less explaining toward the end.
  
Technicalities: Ford … dually?
Watch punctuation,  unless you’re blatantly objecting to it. One ommited word: “of,” in “string [of] pay by the hour hotels,” there are also some commas missing from that sentence – check for them elsewhere in this, and let me know what you do with this.

Definitely a heart warmer, and definitely exposing the rawness and shame of such an error!  Just beautiful.

TrevorSamuels avatar General Stranger

April 01, 2008

TrevorSamuels

REVIEW QUALITY: 0.0%(1 vote ) personal info reviewer stats
TrevorSamuels reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

LOL, QTRHRS, very funny!  I hope no one from Wichita reads this one!  Very cute, I had a good laugh.  

duelingrose avatar General Stranger

April 01, 2008

duelingrose

REVIEW QUALITY: 100.0%(1 vote ) personal info reviewer stats
duelingrose reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

This almost feels like something used as a speech during an anniversary dinner. Which is not a bad thing at all. This is a very personal piece, and it’s filled with a very tangible emotion.

I think you could take this talent for personal writting very far indeed.

Magesius avatar General Stranger

April 01, 2008

Magesius

personal info reviewer stats
Magesius reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

I’m not so great with being a critic on Short Stories so much as poems, but I’ll do my best.  I enjoy the end of the trip part the best.  I mean, its good because it is actually quite funny.  I dont know how married you are to the story as it is, but I wouldnt minds seeing another funny part or two in there.  Even if they are just contrived.  Good effort overall though.

bravis avatar General Stranger

April 01, 2008

bravis Prolific-icon-medium

REVIEW QUALITY: 100.0%(2 votes ) personal info reviewer stats
bravis reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

The second paragraph has lots of very complicated sentences, full of powerful descriptive phrases joined together by commas.  I think many of these could be simplified a little and made easier to read. This would help the paragraph to flow a little better.  In some cases commas are not necessary (“It looked like an old factory town after the factory had gone bust [,] leaving in its wake a depressed city full of filthy…”), and in many cases you could replace the comma with a linking word like “and” which is easier to read (“I’d heard of things like this AND even seen them on television…”), or reduce the number of adjectives (“filthy, seedy, pay-by the hour motels”).  You could also make use of short sentences rather than run-on sentences linked by commas (“No interesting buildings.  No tall buildings.  Nothing…”).  

“a newer Ford F350 four door dually with a ground effects package” – this is a very complex description.  Do we need to know this much about it?  Try to keep references to small details like this simple – wouldn’t “a Ford” do?

“And when I tell that story….Wichita.”  This paragraph was really confusing because it is a subtle shift in style.  Everything up to this point has been addressed to “you” and is you telling this story to your husband, which is a little disconcerting to read because the reader is having to imagine they are your husband.  But this paragraph seems to be out of context because you now seem to be talking about telling the story in the past tense, like you’ve finished telling the story and are reflecting on it…  

I read on a little further and you HAVE finished telling the story.  Oh right.  Not to take away from the happy/funny memories at all, but there’s not much to this story.  It’s an amusing misunderstanding, but I would see this as something to put within another story as an entertaining anecdote or event.  I’m not sure it’s enough for a story on its own.  

I would develop this story as a fiction piece and add a larger story line around the setting and misunderstanding.  I would also change the style and make it less of a letter to your husband and more of an active story.  Write from your point of view in present or past tense and make the reader feel like they are you experiencing events.  This would make for a much easier, more engaging and entertaining read.

placidchaos avatar General Stranger

April 01, 2008

placidchaos Prolific-icon-medium

REVIEW QUALITY: 100.0%(2 votes ) personal info reviewer stats
placidchaos reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

You don’t see many things ever written in second person and I appreciate the viewpoint and applaud you for thinking of it this way. It is letter to the husband that we as readers are privleged to read. I almost feel a little sneaky, like I have opened someone’s dresser drawer and quietly read something very personal.

I really do not know how to approach a critique on this because at first glance it seems perfect for what it is.

Yet, here goes anyway. I like the descriptions of the town while entering, but I feel if this is to be published then maybe you need to add a little more, just to give that total abhorance you seem to feel at this point. Maybe some more detailed descriptions of the buildings; perhaps, peeling paint or grime from the factories smudging the walls. Maybe you could describe the people you might see in an area where there are hotels rented by the hour.

I was once traveling through Amarillo, TX in an area much like you have described. It was just getting dark and the ladies of the eveing were coming out. There is one image that sticks in my mind to this day. I saw a lady who was obiviously dressed for work. She was dressed in the tightest most brightly colored spandex you could find trying to flag down cars as they passed slowly. Next to her, clinging to her leg was alittle girl age about 4-5, desheveled, dirty and dressed only in her panties. She did not even have shoes on her feet. Maybe this not how dark you want this to feel, but then again maybe you do want to give it more dred.

I really, truely enjoyed this piece. I hope to read more of your work in the future. And if you revise this work I would feel privleged to read it again.

Showing 1 - 10 of 11
Next →

Creator
Anonymous

Anonymous

Age: 38
Loc: United States
Gen: ?
Last Login: ?
Relevant Links
Item Stats

GENERAL

11 Reviews 1 Comment
Version 1
Latest Activity: 3 months ago

REVIEW QUEUE

Appeared in Queue: 0 Times
Skipped: 5 Times
Large_criteria Ratings & Rankings
Tags

There are no tags for this item.