Poetry / woe (Analysis)

i have seen the fire of desire
       i have tasted the ice of revenge
             i have walked the dead man’s road
                 i held another’s life in my hands
                       would pray to God i could go back
                             but i’m sure i’d do it again
                                i’m sure my actions were all wronge
                                    when the system failed a righteous man

i’ve walked accross this land
        from sea to shining sea              
                  i’ve seen the darkness
                         i’ve seen the light
                              paying it forward
                                    and might makes right
                                           poor feeding destitute
                                                 the corruption of a child
                                                        God’s wonders i’ve seen
                                                              the devil’s hand made proud

i’ve listen to polititions
      and the man on the street
             making thier chains of slavery
                      while they sing freedom’s song
                              they sing “step up, step
                                      upon your brother’s back
                                            get the money where you can
                                                   bury honor in the sand
                                            
                    

You need to log in to urbis or create an urbis account to review this writing.

Reviews

Sort Reviews by  Newest |  Oldest |  Highest Quality |  Lowest Quality |  Newest Comments | 

 
daphne avatar General Stranger

May 25, 2008

daphne

personal info reviewer stats
daphne reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item
This 194 word review has not been unlocked.
RhysTimson avatar General Stranger

April 21, 2008

RhysTimson

personal info reviewer stats
RhysTimson reviewed Version 1 - Read 100%% of the Item

The opening of the poem ‘references’ Robert Frost’s Fire & Ice, but maybe that’s not a good idea since Frost’s poem is an absolute classic and not much will compete. There are a few spelling errors in here too, e.g. “polititions” should be “politicians” – sorry to be picky.

This had a nice rhythm to it at times and drove along at a fair old pace. The successively increasing indentation is unnecessary however.

A_Alexander avatar General Stranger

April 05, 2008

A_Alexander

personal info reviewer stats
A_Alexander reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

Hi,

”...actions were all wronge”  Im not sure if this is a spelling mistake or intentional. I like it, I think. You need to think about whether or not this will slow the pace or intregue the audience.

“i held another’s life…” I think that I’ve would be stonger here.

You should try to work a recurring theme or image into each stanza to strengthen the overall effect.

I think that this is very strong and with some work would definately be publishable.

thanks for sharing, I hope that this has been helpful

A.Alexander

P.S I think you should try to limit the number of criteria to three or four. It is annoying to try to do ten or so. THanks.  A

Basic_Jane avatar General Stranger

March 31, 2008

Basic_Jane

personal info reviewer stats
Basic_Jane reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

Well, you misspelled wrong and politician, but overall I liked this piece. Personally I’d change L4 to I’ve held another’s hands, L13 to pay it forward, and add the word and to line L26. Also the word system in L8 feels a bit out of place, so you might try finding another word for it.  

Nytefist7 avatar General Stranger

March 31, 2008

Nytefist7

personal info reviewer stats
Nytefist7 reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

I give you a ten for the theme. But the poetry itself…there are alot of overly familiar statements like “sea to shining sea” and “pay it forward”, which I think you may be intending to saturate the piece with these for “mood”,
but it comes off as generic instead. Alot of the lines are simple rhymes like
“fire of desire”. I’m no poet, and I have no special skill set in reviewing it, but I would get rid of the simple rhymes and stale sayings. Find a new, more vigorous way to say “might makes right” etc. Hope this helps.

cnguyen avatar General Stranger

March 29, 2008

cnguyen

personal info reviewer stats
cnguyen reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

The poem successfully painted the picture of a self righteous person questioning his own action and integrity fighting the ‘system’.  I liked the easy flow and the rhythm.  The break at step up, step / upon is interesting (synchopation effect?).    However, I found the last two lines, yes well rhymed, but a little contrived.

By the way, there are a few minor typos here: wronge, polititions and thier.  Also the double quote at “step up… did not have a matching close quote.

Lenore avatar General Stranger

March 28, 2008

Lenore

personal info reviewer stats
Lenore reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

Powerful word use, though I feel confused when tryıng to fınd the meanıng. YOu contrast thıngs lıke fıre and ıce, lıght and darkness, and you talk about mostly bad thıngsş but not enough good thıngs to contrast ıt totally black and whıte.

cybermouse avatar General Stranger

March 28, 2008

cybermouse

personal info reviewer stats
cybermouse reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

It might have been better if you’d told me what those experiences were. They sound as though they might have been fascinating but all I’m left with is this faint echo of what you saw. If we live long enough most of us encounter these things but what make yours so special? Tell me about them. Make each experience a poem that we can share. What kind of ice was in the revenge? was it yours or someone else’s revenge? Who did it happen to? If the last stanza is all the point you are trying to make, then make it the poem and expand on it. I don’t, for instance, understand how these things have made you feel. I want to know if you feel the same way about them that I do or if you have a new slant on them that I never saw before. Go on, tell me…

Regards,
Bill

www.billallerton.co.uk

serenitylace avatar General Stranger

March 28, 2008

serenitylace

personal info reviewer stats
serenitylace reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

lovely. I thought it felt undone, but well written. did you use spelling errors on purpose?

evath avatar General Stranger

March 28, 2008

evath

personal info reviewer stats
evath reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

Some minor spelling and grammatical errors, but nothing
that spellchecker wouldn’t catch and allow you to correct.

I liked your use of the spaces around the stanzas
to create a feeling of motion, but I didn’t understand
their point.

Particularly liked the first stanza and thought it was
strong, despite wrong spelled incorrectly with an “e”

There were some weak imagery that seemed more like
filler against some of your stronger images, or that
seemed there to create flow without adding anything
new or significant. (no offense).

I thoroughly gravitated toward the lines:
“step up. step up(on) your brother’s back
get the money where you can.”
I didn’t care for the last line as I thought
it really weak after the previous line.
Maybe just switch them and make the stronger
line your final line.

bury honor in the sand
while they sing their songs of slavery
“step up, step up(on)... where you can.”

Showing 1 - 10 of 10

Creator
monsterchild60 avatar

monsterchild60

Age: 48
Loc: Willits, CA
Gen: F
Last Login: May 03
Relevant Links
Item Stats

GENERAL

10 Reviews 17 Comments
Version 1
Latest Activity: 3 months ago

REVIEW QUEUE

Appeared in Queue: 14 Times
Skipped: 3 Times
Large_criteria Ratings & Rankings
 Plus-button Clarity
Tags

There are no tags for this item.