Poetry / Orcs & Humans (Analysis)

A sharpened arrow perched to fly
To meet a thousand more that soar
Across the sunset-laden sky,
While heavy footfalls stomp the floor.

A finger shoots into the air—
A piercing sound; a child’s cry.
Chaos rushes here and there
Beneath the sunset-laden sky.

Shouts go up, and tales of lore
Get passed around like broken bread.
Move on and sound the drums of war;
Goodbyes are better left unsaid.

Two forces clash, a willing pair
Of duelers wielding sword and mace
Trying to catch one unaware
And put him in his rightful place.

Upon the bleeding ground, a score
Lay dead, and many wish to die;
No one seems the victor anymore—
Just pawns beneath the sunset-laden sky.

You need to log in to urbis or create an urbis account to review this writing.

Reviews

Sort Reviews by  Newest |  Oldest |  Highest Quality |  Lowest Quality |  Newest Comments | 

 
michaelolsen avatar General Stranger

May 08, 2008

michaelolsen

personal info reviewer stats
michaelolsen reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

This, while having some unsubstantiated references to vague empathic ideas, lacks punch that it could derive from more concrete detail.

amato3 avatar General Stranger

May 01, 2008

amato3

personal info reviewer stats
amato3 reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

Although I am not into Warcraft, I thought this to be a very interesting piece.  You use your words in such a way as to give the reader an excellent visual of what is going on.  I did not understand Stanza 3 line 1 and 2 and how the two lines relate.  Could be my lack of understanding of the subject.  Would love to read more.

OfTrepidation avatar General Stranger

April 08, 2008

OfTrepidation

personal info reviewer stats
OfTrepidation reviewed Version 1 - Read 100%% of the Item

wow! how amazing that something really beautiful and visual can be inspired by a video game? I am not insulting the game, far from it, I have never even played it. I just think this is really beautiful. I especially enjoyed the last verse.

00_Doughboy avatar General Stranger

April 03, 2008

00_Doughboy

personal info reviewer stats
00_Doughboy reviewed Version 1 - Read 100%% of the Item
This 142 word review has not been unlocked.
axelk avatar General Stranger

April 03, 2008

axelk

personal info reviewer stats
axelk reviewed Version 1 - Read 100%% of the Item

For a Warcraft inspired poem I found this to be pretty good. I paid good attention to the last two lines but I think they are ok still the most superficial of them all. The other stanzas are better constructed

ekarbin avatar General Stranger

March 28, 2008

ekarbin

personal info reviewer stats
ekarbin reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

Very nice attention to rhyme and meter.  I enjoyed the narrative very much indeed, even though I am not personally a war epic fan.  The one great mistake a lot of writers make when writing in meter is using inversion to get the rhyme—you did not do too much of that here, but I feel duty-bound to mention it.  Another thing I thought of after reading the second stanza was how much I loved the repetition of the term “sunset-laden sky”, which you very nicely brought back at the end.  Have you considered reworking this piece into a vilanelle?  If you’re not familiar with the form, you really must look it up; the overview is as follows--  a 19 line piece, broken into tercets and ending with a quatrane, writen in aba rhyme, often in pentameter.  Throughout the piece the 1st and 3rd lines weave through the piece, ending each stanza in turn before they both end the last stanza--roughly it looks like this:

1
2
3

4
5
1

6
7
3

8
9
1

10
11
3

12
13
1
3

So, it’s an ambitious project, but one I think you’d be up to.  Also, how’s this for an ending, I opted for subtlty…
There are no victors anymore/ beneath the sunset-laden sky

shinsukato avatar General Stranger

March 26, 2008

shinsukato

personal info reviewer stats
shinsukato reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

A finger shoots into the air—
A piercing sound; a child’s cry.  - can i assume you’re referring to magic here? If so, I think that it’s a little too vague for people to get the idea.

The meter of the poem falters in the last paragraph. Since this is a fairly rhythmic poem, that faltering at the end can leave a somewhat bad impression.

Very entertaining though, I enjoyed reading it. Thanks for the read.

browniie111 avatar General Stranger

March 25, 2008

browniie111

personal info reviewer stats
browniie111 reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

“While heavy footfalls stomp the floor.” The floor? are they inside? This takes away from the rest of the poem because it sounds so much less sophisticated

“A finger shoots into the air—” do you mean literally that someones finger is shooting into the air? because that is what it sounds like.

“Beneath the sunset-laden sky.” the second time. that is good because it ties the second stanza back to the first

“Two forces clash, a willing pair
Of duelers wielding sword and mace
Trying to catch one unaware
And put him in his rightful place.” This is the strongest part of the poem. It shows both sides of the fight.

“Upon the bleeding ground, a score
Lay dead, and many wish to die;
No one seems the victor anymore—
Just pawns beneath the sunset-laden sky.” This is a very good ending. First becuase you are showing the end of the battle but also because you are in a way tying up the loose ends and creating the time frame of one day by saying “Just pawns beneath the sunset-laden sky.”

atm1721 avatar General Stranger

March 24, 2008

atm1721

personal info reviewer stats
atm1721 reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

Perhaps you can use:
“No one seems the victor for
Pawns beneath the laden sky.”
I dont know i tried.  I hope you figure out what sounds the best.  This seems like it has potential for greatness. I agree to me that seems to be the only part that doesn’t flow as well as the rest of the piece.  Too bad its the last part of the piece, because that needs to be the best to wrap it up, and the words you have are perfect if they fit your rhyme scheme a bit better.  Thanks for sharing. I enjoyed reading this.

Showing 1 - 9 of 9

Creator
poeticLicense avatar

poeticLicense

Age: 24
Loc: Sumter, SC
Gen: F
Last Login: September 23
Relevant Links
Item Stats

GENERAL

9 Reviews 3 Comments
Version 1
Latest Activity: 3 months ago

REVIEW QUEUE

Appeared in Queue: 0 Times
Skipped: 3 Times
Large_criteria Ratings & Rankings
Tags

There are no tags for this item.