This page is part of the portfolio of urbis user Claire_D, which lists reviews they have completed which have been revealed.
The item you were looking for was deleted.
Reviews
Is this one of these notorious drabbles? It falls 24 words short if so. If not, I do apologise. The images are vivid, emotive and conjure up a sense of springtime in the air amid old-house loss and death. Main problems are punctuation. ‘half- hinged’ > extra space ‘here .Suddenly’ > wrong space I like the H alliteration throughout. The letter fits the scene like a glove. ‘No… left’ > italicise this, or place a comma after ‘left’ ‘jewels’ > the comb jewels are figurative, yes? My p...
Great opening. Tone swizzles from commonplace insulting to insulting in a hilarious manner. Nice. ‘Erin…’ > hyphen needed? Erin Brockovich was campaigning against the unpleasant chemicals, was she not? This sounds as though she was being the naughty one. ‘Pretty…’ > OK, is should be there, but I laughed. Tone makes it OK. ‘around’ > can be cut. ‘train-station’ > no hyphen here either. You like hyphenating, don’t you? That’s cute. Insults are hilarious and resonant. Pantsuit is a s...
Your title has all the hallmarks of a word-hugging student seeking to bedazzle with his language and mind-expanding ideas. Probably under the influence of psychotropic herbal remedies. Welcome, Duddbud. ‘newgrounds’ > this elusive concept deserves capitalisation. ‘chinese’ should also be capitalised. ‘it’s’ > the first three uses in this story should be its ‘exculpation’ > is a barbarous sounding word, with the ‘scalp’ similarity and the harshness of ‘culp’ beside the negation of the...
Enjoyable blog. I like the staccato vibe and the rough-and-tumble Thompsonesque flow. I respect that informal blog patois has been used, but since most bloggers aspire to the eloquence of novelists, or the eloquence of blogger-novelists, here are some suggestions: ‘out of my’ > from my Facebook friends list. ‘that it’ > dodgy, it… ‘out of his’ > out about his… ‘why…E-bay’ > To the outsider, this lacks context. The other rhetorical questions could apply to the unnamed creep, but th...
100.0% Review Quality (2 Votes)
I can’t say your haircut grabs me. I never liked blue perms on teenage boys. Points: ‘life of one…’ > repetition of life ruins the elegance of this sentence. This repeat would work if it was flagged up as humorous. ‘then… ago’ > I wanted a more immediate timeframe here. Is this set in the present? How long ago is then? Vague detail, so it’s less grabbing. ‘self induced’ > is hyphenated ‘bitter’ > I would snip this word. I had a problem with the notion of ‘self-induced irascibility...
First snag for me was the tense in the second paragraph. I think, ‘have noticed’ or simply ‘you noticed’ would be more pleasing to the ear. The Tin Man’s interjection – does this follow on from a feeling of impatience around another myth being shattered (i.e. like that of the bricks)? I thought his sarcastic interjection needed qualifying… as though he’d been listening for a while and had become impatient. ‘mechanical mandible’ > is witty and charming. I liked. ‘fringe… question’ > mayb...
100.0% Review Quality (3 Votes)
Hilarious. Eine kleine Freude. Schadenfreude, perhaps. First stanza slathers on the grotesquerie to such an extent that a strange warped beauty emerges from the relentless yuk-yuk of the images. Like a wanky teenager attempting to shock with his bilious outpourings, the true desolation of his soul oozes forth from his indigent self-expression. Such is the case with this work. Yucky = pretty. Pretty = vacant. ‘half-flaccid’ > A snail’s body is fully flaccid, no? The shell is nice and hard, ...
66.6667% Review Quality (3 Votes)
A sublime piece of writing. The inner-worlds (internet IDs) and the outer-worlds (their real selves) are blurred to such an extent, a form of unreality has taken over in these characters’ lives, corrupting truths. The bipolar motif of assuming false IDs on the web is a fascinating psychological aside. Very entertaining work. Mechanics: ‘in back’ > out back? ‘neighbourhood Italian’ > maybe switch the order of these. ‘brown chairs’ > banal detail… something unique/specific about the ch...
Bunny's grumpy. Better placate him with pandour-juice. Things: ‘snap… spaghetti’ > spaghetti melts into a mulch when it’s overcooked, there’s no snapping involved. ‘zit-popping stained’ > I read these as being two separate adjectives, when I think you’re trying to link the two. Maybe ‘zit-pop stained’. ‘Razors’ > perhaps speech marks, to indicate the Yeti is speaking? ‘pubes’ > With ‘disobedient’ I pictured a tuft of pubic hair, so I felt pruning scissors were appropriate. Pubic h...
100.0% Review Quality (2 Votes)
Good rewrite. Smoother and tighter, and keeps (most) of the highlights from V1. ‘chaffing’ > ‘teasing’ would work better IMO. I’m not made about two verbs ‘interjected’ and ‘chaffed’ being side by side, so I thought ‘cut in the Tin Man, teasing the scarecrow’ would be better. Just a thought. ‘stated’ > something more disgusted? Spat? Scoffed? I see you’ve kept the stutter but lost the nice line after it. Aww. 'ecologically' > still going with? It bothers me less this time round, afte...
Overview

